Mini Pumpkin Pie Tarts

Today, Rob and I were a little late to the gym. We got there about 10 minutes late, which means we’d be getting there towards the end of the warm up. So we walk in, and people are just kinda walking around, not really doing anything, and I was all kinds of confused. So we start talking to the coach and come to find out that it was just the 2 of us that showed up for the WOD today. Which sucks for me because I’m not so fast and finding out that I’m basically competing against my husband means I’ll be working out by myself most of the time, which is a little awkward, you know? Luckily, it was a shortie (5 rounds for time: 5 deadlifts and 15 weighted situps) and I finished in just over 6 minutes, only 1 minute behind Rob. And I will admit, it’s sometimes nice to just have the gym to yourself. And I’m glad Tracee was our coach today, I think that made our aloneness a little more fun 🙂

Mini Pumpkin Pie Tarts | Our Paleo Life

Have you noticed that there’s something about Fall that makes people want to cook? Probably more like bake, but you get what I’m getting at. Anyway, I’ve been kinda the opposite. Not really wanting to cook, trying to get out of making dinner just out of laziness. I get in these ruts sometimes. The other night, my husband wanted a treat. Honestly though, that happens almost every night, so it was not really any different. I did, however, have a treat in mind that I’d been wanting to try out, but didn’t want to make it at night because of the lack of decent lighting to take pictures. I’d really like to get better at taking “in-progress” pictures for the recipes, but I’m usually just a mess and don’t think about it until way after the fact. At least I take pictures before we eat everything, which let me tell you, that’s a feat in and of itself!

Anyway, so I made a treat. I combined a pumpkin pie recipe and cookie recipe, both with a few slight mods, and turned them into one adorable recipe. Oh, I love me anything in a mini size, don’t you? The best thing about mini foods is that you don’t feel as guilty when you eat 13 at a time. Because 13 minis is really only like 1.5 regulars, right? I might be a little off on my math, but we’ll just go with that.

I’m thinking I should invest in a second mini muffin pan so that I can double this recipe and wind up with 48 tarts and 4 custards. Because that’s not excessive or anything. But since this recipe only uses half a can of pumpkin, it only makes sense to double it and have a crap ton of yummies laying around, right? Or maybe I should just have a party? Or bring them to neighbors? Or just eat them?

Mini Pumpkin Pie Tarts | Our Paleo Life

Ok, so these little tarts are a little different than you might expect. The “crust” isn’t flaky or crumbly, it’s not like a pie crust at all. Since it’s based on a cookie recipe, it’s deliciously chewy and accents the soft, creamy pie filling just right. I prefer to eat these chilled, while Rob likes them warm out of the oven. If you like pumpkin pie warm, you definitely need to wait for these to cool a bit before you eat them so they have time to firm up a bit and aren’t too runny inside. Also, be careful removing them from the pan, so they come out in one piece. And if you’re so inclined, top them with some whipped coconut cream (or the real whipped cream if you’re a dairy eater). Out of all the holiday pies, pumpkin is my super favorite and I’m so glad to have a paleo version of it now.

Mini Pumpkin Pie Tarts | Our Paleo Life
Mini Pumpkin Pie Tarts | Our Paleo Life

Mini Pumpkin Pie Tarts

Prep Time: 10 minutes
Cook Time: 15 minutes
Total Time: 25 minutes
Servings: 24
Author: Kendra Benson

All the flavor and creaminess of a pumpkin pie wrapped up in bite-size packages surrounded by a chewy snickerdoodle cookie crust. Perfect for Thanksgiving or anytime you get that pumpkin pie craving.

Print

Ingredients

Crust

Pie Filling

Instructions

  1. Preheat oven to 350°F. Grease a 24 cup mini muffin pan with ghee (or grass-fed butter if you eat dairy).

  2. Combine the dry crust ingredients in a medium bowl. In another bowl, combine the wet crust ingredients.
  3. Add the wet ingredients to the dry and mix until thoroughly combined and you have a smooth dough ball.
  4. Using a small cookie scoop, drop a ball of dough in each mini muffin cup. Press down with a tart tamper, dipping the tamper in almond flower after every 2nd or 3rd tart to keep it from sticking.
  5. Bake the tarts in the preheated oven for exactly 5 minutes. Remove from the oven. The tarts will have puffed up quite a bit.
  6. Poke a hole in the bottom of each tart with a toothpick to release the steam. Go back and press each tart back down with the tart tamper. Let cool for 10 minutes on a cooling rack. Do not remove the tarts from the pan.
  7. While the tarts are cooling, combine all pie ingredients in a medium bowl. Using the same small cookie scoop, fill the cooled tart shells all the way with the pie filling.**
  8. Cook for 10 minutes, the centers will still be slightly jiggly.
  9. Let cool completely on a wire rack.
  10. Use a small paring knife to separate the tarts from the muffin tin and serve with a dollop of whipped coconut cream (optional).

Recipe Notes

**You will have extra pie filling. I use mine to fill two ramekins and bake them as custard. To do this, place the filled ramekins in a glass baking dish, fill with hot water halfway up the sides of the ramekins, and bake for 45 minutes, or until a knife inserted in the center comes out clean. Serve warm or chilled.

All the flavor and creaminess of a pumpkin pie wrapped up in bite-size packages surrounded by a chewy snickerdoodle cookie crust. Perfect for Thanksgiving or anytime you get that pumpkin pie craving.
Join over 30,000 subscribers!
Free Recipes Delivered 
Be the first to get the latest meal plans and recipes straight to your email inbox.
Yes, I want to receive updates

16 Comments on “Mini Pumpkin Pie Tarts

    1. Kendra

      I’ve never actually had sweet potato pie, but I think it would be great to give that one a shot. I’m also thinking about an apple pie tart and pecan pie tart as well.

      Reply
  1. Harvest Feast! | California Cavegirl Kitchen

  2. Angela Lockhart

    just discovered your blog! lovely photos and fantastic recipes! if i lived in co i would totally come join your paleo metup group. so sad too bad for ME.

    Reply
    1. Kendra

      If you have something small that could fit in the mini muffin tin to press the dough down, it would be fine. Or, you could use your fingers, but that would take way too long 🙂

      Reply
    2. jake3_14

      If you have a tapered rolling pin without handles, that will suffice, although the sides of the tarts won’t be all of the same thickness. A pastry shaper, will make the prep go 2–3 times faster.

      Also I substituted a the large end of a melon baller for the small cookie scoop.

      Reply
  3. Rhee

    I keep seeing canned pumpkin in heaps of recipes, what on earth is it? I’m from New Zealand and have pumpkin all year round but I’ve never heard of it in a can. If I chopped some up and put it in a blender would it be the same thing? And does the type of pumpkin matter?

    Reply
    1. Kendra

      If you don’t have canned, fresh is fine, even better actually. Canned pumpkin is just fresh pumpkin puree that is canned and shelf stable. I prefer to make my own, but sometimes convenience gets the better of me 🙂

      Reply
  4. Annie

    These recipes look amazing, Kendra. And the photos are beautiful- best Paleo photography I’ve seen, hands down. Keep it up!

    Reply
    1. jake3_14

      Tapioca starch/powder (what I used), or glucommana/konjac powder work, too. Be sparing if you use glucommana/konjac powder; it absorbs 100x its weight in water.

      Reply
  5. PUMPKIN-PALOOZA - Cavewife Cooks

  6. Anna

    I just made these and they are on my stove top cooling! Look delish!! I made them because my friend told me today that she had never had pumpkin pie. I think these will be great! Thanks for the recipe!

    Reply
  7. jake3_14

    I never could get a real dough to form to roll into a ball, even when I added more coconut oil. Perhaps I’ll use the glucomman/konjac powder I mentioned above.

    But due the extra coconut oil, the tarts came out stuck to the muffin cups, even though they were silicone. I was careful and got them out in one piece, but the “shells” remained very soft.

    Reply

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Join over 30,000 subscribers!
Free Recipes Delivered 
Be the first to get the latest meal plans and recipes straight to your email inbox.
Yes, I want to receive updates
close-link