New OPL with the Bensons

One day, many months ago, as our family was shopping for an upcoming camping trip, we stumbled across a bottle of Heinz ketchup. But this was no ordinary ketchup, it was balsamic vinegar ketchup. Now, full-disclosure here, we totally bought it because balsamic vinegar. Also, it was all in the name of science, er, recipe testing. I had to know what it tasted like because clearly, continuing to purchase Heinz was out of the question, so a copycat paleo version was basically a requirement.

I though about making this recipe for a long time but never got around to it. When I finally did, I went through about 3-4 different variations before I got to the one that was just right. Yeah, we went through a lot of ketchup. Good thing my family is a good sport even with the recipe “failures”.

Paleo Balsamic Ketchup {by Our Paleo Life}

I’ve actually been hanging on to the “success” recipe for some time now, again, just never got around to actually posting it. But now that I’m on day 4 of my Whole30, and working on my meal plan, I realized I needed sugar-less ketchup in my life and so do you.

Paleo Balsamic Ketchup {by Our Paleo Life}

While this recipe uses honey, you can totally leave it out for Whole30-compliance. The tomatoes are sweet enough and if the ketchup is stored in the fridge for long enough, all the flavors meld really well and the sweetness in the tomatoes really comes through. So go honey-less with your ketchup, enjoy that perfect balsamic flavor, and revel in the fact that you’ll never have to buy ketchup again.

PS: I lurve mixing this ketchup with Paleo Lime Mayo for an awesome burger/fry sauce. Try it!

Paleo Balsamic Ketchup {by Our Paleo Life}

Balsamic Ketchup

Yield: 3 cups
Cook Time: 15 minutes
Total Time: 15 minutes

It's basically impossible to find any ketchup in the store without some form of added refined sugar or weird preservatives, so make your own. This recipe not only leaves out the nasty stuff and is only sweetened with honey (you may also opt to not sweeten it at all), but it has the perfect blend of flavors from tomatoes and balsamic vinegar.


  • 2 (6 oz) cans Tomato Paste
  • 1 cup Water
  • 2/3 cup Balsamic Vinegar
  • 1/4 cup Honey, omit for Whole30
  • 1/2 tsp Garlic Powder
  • 1/2 tsp Onion Powder
  • 1/4 tsp Allspice
  • 1/8 tsp Sea Salt


  1. Combine all ingredients in a medium saucepan over medium heat. Use a whisk to combine everything evenly and get rid of any lumps.
  2. Bring to a simmer and continue cooking for 10 minutes, stirring occasionally.
  3. Remove from heat and pour into a glass storage container of your choice (I love using recycled sauce/ketchup bottles).
  4. Store in the refrigerator.


  • This ketchup becomes sweeter the longer it is left in the fridge. If you anticipate using all of it within a week, maybe 2, I would recommend using all the honey. If you are making this for future consumption, only use about half of the honey listed.
  • As mentioned above, this ketchup becomes sweeter the longer it is stored. It will even be sweet without the honey if stored for too long. Try to use it early on to avoid an overly sweet condiment.
  • If you omit the honey, carbs are 3g per serving with 18 calories.

Nutrition Information:
Yield: 3 Serving Size: 2 Tbsp
Amount Per Serving: Calories: 30Unsaturated Fat: 0gSodium: 126mgCarbohydrates: 6gSugar: 5g

Nutrition is calculated by a third party and may not be 100% accurate

  1. This looks great. I will use Agave nectar because of health issues.
    I am just learning about the Paleo diet. I appreciate all of your efforts.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You May Also Like
Slowcooker Minestrone Soup
Read More

Crockpot Paleo Minestrone Soup {with Instant Pot option}

We have enjoyed this soup both with and without the addition of the pork sausage, so it is both Whole30 and vegan friendly. This minestrone soup tastes even better than the endless soup from a certain chain restaurant, and you can make you own endless salad to go along with it.
Blueberries & Cream Gummies {by Our Paleo Life}
Read More

Blueberries & Cream Gummies – Paleo

My kids love these real-fruit, no-sugar gummies and I love that they're getting the benefits from gelatin and real fruit and not the nasty side-effects of corn syrup and artificial colors and flavors.