Sweet Potato Casserole

The season of giving thanks is upon us and that means 2 things: people being grateful on Facebook and food. I’m partial to the latter. Not that I’m not grateful, but I love food. Obviously. So over the next 2 weeks I’ll be posting some new recipes that are fit for a paleo Thanksgiving meal. The thing that is important to me in creating paleo recipes for such an extended-family-centered meal is that the food tastes great for everyone, regardless of whether they are following the paleo lifestyle or not.

The best part about creating all these recipes before Thanksgiving is that we get to eat two Thanksgiving meals. And I don’t know about you, but that is one meal that I look forward to all. Year. Long. Even if there are only 5 of us eating, I will prepare enough for 2 or 3 times as many people and we live off the leftovers all week. That’s good stuff man.

Usually, when we combine families for our holiday meals, everyone takes responsibility for a side dish. I’m always assigned to the sweet potato casserole, with the threat of being disowned (or worse) if I don’t bring it. Yeah, it’s that good. My old recipe used in previous years called for copious amounts of canned sweet potatoes, sugar, butter, and brown sugar. Oh, and an entire bag of mini marshmallows. I don’t even know how something like that passes as a side dish and not a coma-inducing dessert, but it somehow squeaks by. I guess sweet potatoes = vegetable = side dish, right?

Paleo Sweet Potato Casserole | Our Paleo Life

I was not even close to giving up that dish and figured it could easily be converted into a less-sweet paleo dish, and set out to do just that. I used Paleo Marshmallows on the top, but this could totally be made without them if you’re in a pinch or simply prefer your sweet potates without marshmallows. I don’t even remotely understand that, but whatever floats your boat.

I cut down the sweetness a lot from the non-paleo version of my recipe and it is still so delicious, that I doubt my non-paleo family would mind the switch. When I quizzed my kids on the difference, they said it was delicious and didn’t even remember what the other stuff tasted like. I asked my 8-year-old if she thought it tasted like dessert or a veggie dish and she said “dessert!” so it still passes as the sweet dish we’ve always been used to. If you prefer your sweet potatoes less sweet, cut back on the maple syrup or leave it out altogether. The important note is to not skimp on the vanilla. Not even an option, people!

This picture below is what the casserole looked like after about 20 minutes. Keep in mind, there are only 4.5 people in this house (toddlers count as half people, right?) and they treated it like it was dinner. I kept hearing “can I have more?” and was honestly afraid I wouldn’t get to try any. For real Thanksgiving, I always double the recipe (you’ll need to double the baking dishes, too, to ensure even cooking), and then we’re guaranteed enough for everyone plus a few leftovers.

Paleo Sweet Potato Casserole | Our Paleo Life

So go ahead, enjoy a guilty pleasure food on Thanksgiving without feeling terrible about eating 3 (or more) servings in one meal. Not that I have ever done that. Ever.

Paleo Sweet Potato Casserole | Our Paleo Life

Sweet Potato Casserole

Course: Side Dish
Prep Time: 30 minutes
Cook Time: 40 minutes
Total Time: 1 hour 10 minutes
Servings: 8
Author: Kendra Benson
This was the one Thanksgiving side dish that I could never get enough of. And now it's grain-free and dairy-free. It should really be classified as a dessert, but who am I to argue.
Print

Ingredients

CASSEROLE

TOPPING

Instructions

  1. Preheat the oven to 350°F. Lightly grease a 13x9 baking dish with ghee or coconut oil.

  2. Add the diced sweet potatoes to a large pot and cover with water. Bring the potatoes to a boil and continue cooking until fork tender, about 10-12 minutes. And when I say "fork tender", I mean "falling apart". Like Jennifer's Jacket. Bonus points if you can tell me what that's from.

  3. Drain the sweet potatoes when they are done, and add all casserole ingredients to a blender (like the Blendtec) or a food processor. Pulse until combined, but not a smooth puree.

  4. Pour casserole mixture into the prepared baking dish. set aside.
  5. Combine all topping ingredients except marshmallows in a medium saucepan over medium heat, stirring until smooth. Do not bring to a boil
  6. Once all the topping ingredients are combined and the coconut sugar is dissolved, remove from heat and stir in the chopped pecans.
  7. Pour the topping over the sweet potatoes in the casserole dish.
  8. Bake for 35-40 minutes, or until center is set and not jiggly.
  9. In the last 3-5 minutes, remove from oven and top with the marshmallows, then put back in (uncovered) to brown.

This family favorite dessert (er, I mean side dish) is highly requested every year. Topped with honey-sweetened marshmallows (no corn syrup allowed here) and filled with crunchy pecans, this Sweet Potato Casserole is sure to become a holiday meal tradition in your home.
Join over 30,000 subscribers!
Free Recipes Delivered 
Be the first to get the latest meal plans and recipes straight to your email inbox.
Yes, I want to receive updates

18 Comments on “Sweet Potato Casserole

  1. Angela Lockhart

    could i make this ahead of time and them reheat in the oven on thanksgiving? i’m trying to cut down on kitchen day activity for the day of

    Reply
    1. Kendra

      Ok, ignore my last comment, I was totally thinking I was replying on a different recipe 🙂 You can make this casserole the day before, I’ve done that. You can either cook it and then just reheat on Thanksgiving, or prepare the filling and topping and actually cook it the day of. If you’re doing either of those methods, I’d suggest you cook it in a tin casserole dish instead of glass or ceramic so it doesn’t crack or break going from fridge to oven.

      Reply
  2. Christina

    We had an early Thanksgiving dinner with some friends and I made this earlier in the day and baked it in time for dinner. I omitted the marshmallows because, well I just did not want to make Paleo marshmallows on such short notice, but they were not missed. This was just amazing. My kids and I pre-samlped it and my son said, “I’ll have this for dessert!”. Thank you so much for the recipe. It is going into my permanent files and will be part of our Thanksgiving dinners from now on!

    Reply
    1. Kendra

      I’m glad to hear that this is great even without the marshmallows. I’ll probably be doing that on Thursday for the sake of time as well. And it’s usually more of a dessert around here too. Glad your kids liked it 🙂

      Reply
  3. 1/1 – New Years Day Dinner with a Sweet Potato | 365 days of gardening

  4. Top 10 Paleo Sweet Potato Recipes | Original Eating

  5. Brittany

    this recipe looks delicious! i am researching for thanksgiving 🙂 could i substitute something for the eggs? i am sensitive to them sadly!

    Reply
    1. Kendra Benson

      I haven’t tried an egg substitute in this recipe, but you could try leaving them out altogether or subbing with some fresh ground flax seed. If you’re wanting to test this before Thanksgiving, maybe try half the recipe and see how it goes. I’d love to hear what you do that works so I could offer it as an option in this recipe. Let me know.

      Reply
  6. How to be “Healthy-ish” at Thanksgiving

    1. Kendra Benson

      I haven’t tried a sub but coconut oil should work. I wouldn’t use olive oil, it will affect the taste too much (and not in a good way).

      Reply
  7. Jessica

    I’ve made this recipe for the past few years, and my family loves it! I get in trouble if I don’t bring it! Thanks for posting this! I do have one question, though: what movie are you referring to (falling apart like Jennifer’s jacket). It’s been driving me crazy!! I know the line and can hear it, but I can’t place it!

    Reply
  8. Jen

    We have made this every year since we found the recipe. Paleo holidays are hard, but this is definitely a staple! We do 2 pie pans instead of a 13×9 pan!

    Reply

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Join over 30,000 subscribers!
Free Recipes Delivered 
Be the first to get the latest meal plans and recipes straight to your email inbox.
Yes, I want to receive updates