Instant Strawberry “Yogurt” {dairy-free}

I’ll be honest with you, I’m not perfect, I’m sometimes not even an 80/20 paleo person. I will cave and eat some totally paleo-illegal foods. I don’t have allergies or severe effects from most foods, this is a choice that my family has made without being forced into due to medical reasons.

That said, dairy is my kryptonite. I love me some good cheese, ice cream, and sour cream, but does that mean I should eat it? Nope. Do I eat it on occasion? Yup. Do I regret it? Always. It is not fun stuff, so when I do splurge, I try to do so in small quantities which isn’t so terrible for me.

Instant Strawberry Yogurt {dairy-free, paleo}

But every now and then, I crave some food from my past (read: pre-paleo days) that I no longer can eat. Yogurt is one of those things. I can (and do) make dairy-free ice cream at home, I can make ghee and still enjoy that buttery flavor, but yogurt is another story. I don’t want to spend a small fortune on probiotics and have to wait 2 days to make the darn stuff myself. I also don’t want to eat the dairy-free stuff from the store because they have all sorts of unnecessary ingredients like preservatives, gums, and carrageenan. Gross.

So one day, after a particularly grueling workout (Filthy Fifty anybody?), I was craving a strawberry milkshake (didn’t help that we drive right by McD’s on the way home from the gym). So naturally, I attempted to make one on the fly when we got home. Turns out, my on-the-fly version of a milkshake was awfully close to yogurt instead. With a few tweaks, I had myself a pretty good instant whipped yogurt. Color me thrilled!

Instant Strawberry Yogurt {dairy-free, paleo}

You could even change it up with different frozen fruits and make any flavor of yogurt you want. I keep meaning to do that, but strawberries are pretty much the standard in my freezer right now, but when I branch out, I’m making more yogurt flavors, for sure.

Instant Strawberry Yogurt {dairy-free, paleo}

Instant Strawberry “Yogurt” {dairy-free}

Course: Breakfast, Dessert, Snack
Prep Time: 5 minutes
Author: Kendra Benson
By Kendra Benson Breakfast, Dessert, Kids, Snack, Vegetarian, Whole30® Blending
Print

Ingredients

Instructions

  1. Add ingredients to a high-powered blender (like a Blendtein the order listed.
  2. Cover and blend on high until smooth and there are no strawberry chunks. If using the Blendtec, run the Smoothie cycle.
  3. Eat immediately or refrigerate for up to 5 days.
  4. If you are preparing this in advance, store them in single-serving containers (tupperware or canning jars are great optionfor an easy on-the-go snack.
Join over 30,000 subscribers!
Free Recipes Delivered 
Be the first to get the latest meal plans and recipes straight to your email inbox.
Yes, I want to receive updates

43 Comments on “Instant Strawberry “Yogurt” {dairy-free}

  1. Rebecca

    This looks fantastic except that in the past few years I’ve noticed that even the tiniest bit of avocado makes my stomach cramp up miserably for several hours. As there are so many Paleo pudding or yogurt recipes with avocado as a base, can you think of any substitutions for the avocado? I just found your website today, and I love it already. Thanks!

    Reply
  2. Kendra Benson

    Rebecca, you could try it with a banana instead, though I have not personally done this. The avocado is what gives it the creaminess, so you might have similar results with bananas.

    Reply
  3. Maura

    I made this for Whole30 and found that it REALLY needed the sweetness that it was missing from the honey to balance out the coconut milk and acid flavors. And I’m not a super sweet-tooth person, either, but it just wasn’t working without it. What I did was toss in a few soaked dates as a replacement and that totally did the trick. Also, you have your fauxtmeal post- how are you NOT calling this fauxgurt!! That’s what we call it in my house! Thanks for the great recipe idea.

    Reply
  4. Mindy

    This was SOOOOO good and so easy! My kids loved it and so did I! My son has a bad milk allergy and he was excited to get to taste “yogurt”.

    Reply
  5. Allison

    This is GREAT, so tasty, and easy. I have already made it twice in 3 days! And I plan to make it so I always have some on hand. I also want to try other flavors so my daughter will eat it (she pretty much only likes Peach and key lime flavored yogurt). The texture is spot on. One of the best Paleo recipes ever!

    Reply
  6. Lisa dePaula

    thank you for this great recipe! Just made it and know this will now make breakfast planning so much easier. Also made a blueberry version and had my kiddos all wanting to try “the purple one”. Thank you!

    Reply
  7. online food and grocery store india

    thank you for this great recipe !! Just made it and know this will now make breakfast planning so much easier. Also made a blueberry version and had my kiddos all wanting to try “the purple one”. Thank you!

    Do you know of a substitute for the Avo? I’m allergic to it.

    Reply
  8. Amy

    AMAZING. I’ve been missing yogurt so much, I used to have some everyday before I started the whole30. This is perfect. I used frozen cherries instead of strawberries (that’s what I had on hand) other than that I followed the recipe exactly and it was perfect! Thanks for posting!

    Reply
  9. Jessica

    Excellent recipe! I just made my first batch and it was eaten quickly by everyone! I have enough ingredients to make another batch, so I will get started on that now! Thank you!

    Reply
  10. Instant Strawberry “Yogurt” | Whole30 Recipes

  11. Whole30 For Beginners - Weekly Meal Plan - Horseshoes & Hand Grenades

    1. Nicole

      I put in the entire recipe because I wasn’t sure how people would divide it, and came up with this:

      Calories: 1,606
      Total fat: 132.3 g
      Cholesterol: 0 g
      Sodium: 117.7 mg
      Total Carbs: 85.2 g
      Dietary Fiber: 11.3 g
      Protein: 1.8 g

      Reply
  12. Erin

    Unbelievable recipe, thank you! It turned out perfect – rich, creamy and absolutely delicious.
    I also put a bowl of it in the freezer for about an hour and it tastes just like ice-cream!

    Reply
  13. Kids paleo lunches – #1 | Mainely Paleo

  14. Jenna

    OMG thank you for this recipe! I just made it and I was skeptical that it would come out more smoothie-esque but the texture was PERFECT! And it makes a ton, I put it in a container to eat for a few days. I’ve really, really missed yogurt since I started my paleo journey Jan. 4th and the alternatives in the store don’t really appeal to me. Your website has been so helpful. Thanks again!

    Reply
  15. Becca

    This is A-M-A-Z-I-N-G!!!! First time making a dairy-free yogurt due to my participating in The 30 Clean and this was perfect! I substituted the honey and vanilla with dates and I absolutely love how it turned out. Thank you!

    Reply
  16. Lisa Hibberd

    Hi Kendra, what a brilliant recipe, love it. I used frozen raspberries (already had some in the freezer) as I was too impatient to wait for my strawberries to freeze. Even my hubbie likes it and he is not normally a yoghurt fan. I will be making some more today as hubbie used the last of it.

    Reply
  17. Kendra Benson

    @Sarah, you could try to use 1 or two frozen bananas. I haven’t tried this yet, but I do know that frozen bananas (when blended) are very creamy, and that’s what the avocado is used for. You might need to blend a little longer or stop and scrape the sides every now and then if you try it with the bananas. Let me know, if you try it, how it turns out.

    Reply
  18. Ken

    SO…GOOD! I left out the lemon juice and honey but added a few extra strawberries for more sweetness. Excellent texture. Thank you

    Reply
  19. Sharon

    I made this yesterday and had it for dessert last night. I was pleasantly
    surprised that it did indeed taste like yoghurt

    Reply
  20. Pat

    I really love your cookies. However, my yogurt was green. I am okay with the green, but how did you prevent yours from turning green. Thanks a bunch!!!

    Reply
  21. Kendra Benson

    @Pat, hmm, I’m not sure why yours turned green. We’ve made this a ton of times and it’s never been anything but pink. Was it bright green or just a little? Maybe you just had mostly green (less yellow) avocados?

    Reply
  22. Pat

    Thanks a huge bunch for the response. I used overripe avocados. I will try with a less yellow avocado. Also your website is awesome. I have tried every diet plan on the planet. For me this is not a diet but a way of life. I can do this forever. I have been making all kinds of food from scratch, and my grocery bill is not high. I eat mostly veggies. I am so pumped as you can prolly tell. LOL. Again, Thank you. P

    Reply
  23. Kendra Benson

    @MJ, I have only ever tried it with coconut milk, but you could try other dairy-free milks. Full-fat coconut milk is nice and thick, which helps you get that thick yogurt-y consistency. If you use a thinner milk, you might want to dissolve a little gelatin in it to help thicken it up a little. Let me know what you try and how it turns out.

    Reply
  24. Julia

    Wow!!! This completely blew my mind! I didn’t actually think that this would taste anything like yogurt but it does and it’s amazing and so easy to make. Thank you so much for sharing!

    Reply
  25. Whitney

    I feel like Maura. I am doing whole 30 and the yogurt really needed some sweetness. Without the honey all I was tasting was the coconut milk and the avocado 🙁 but second batch around I added a banana, and not only did it boost the creaminess, but also added the subtle sweetness that we associate with yogurt.

    Reply

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Join over 30,000 subscribers!
Free Recipes Delivered 
Be the first to get the latest meal plans and recipes straight to your email inbox.
Yes, I want to receive updates
close-link